Simplify hiring with an interview scoring system

Finding new employees involves making decisions that shouldn’t always rely on your gut instinct alone. Once you post your job opening and reach the interview stage of the hiring process, it helps to use a rating system to compare applicants and choose the best fit for your open position. 

Not sure where to start? Check out a rundown of the basics below. Then, download this template to create a ready-made scoring sheet tailored to the needs of your team and business. 

Homebase Interview scoring sheet template

Why use a scoring system?

An interview scoring system helps you easily rate applicants based on the qualifications you’re seeking for the role. 

With a scoring system, you can objectively measure and compare applicants based on how they answer questions related to: 

  • Relevant experience
  • Hard and soft skills
  • Culture fit 
  • And other important areas of consideration

How to use an interview scoring sheet

Structure your interview with the right questions 

A good interview is all about what you ask the applicant — and how you score their answers. A structured list of questions that are the same for every candidate keeps your interview process consistent and objective. 

Choose relevant questions based on necessary soft skills, common workplace challenges, and levels of experience. For more help with interview questions, check out our article on how to nail each stage of the hiring process.  

Take presentation into account

An interview isn’t only about how a candidate answers questions — presentation matters as well. The impact of a good handshake, eye contact, and preparation level can often be left to your personal intuition. But why not put some numbers behind these qualities? 

The presentation section of your system allows you to score applicants on how they carry themselves during the interview as a whole. Not only will it help you sort out your gut feeling, but it will also make it easier to identify who would be a great fit for your workplace culture. 

Settle on your scoring system 

A good system scores on a scale of 1-5, with firm descriptions behind each value. For example:

1 The candidate didn’t answer the question.

2: The candidate was unable to expand on this answer. 

3: The candidate hit on some key aspects of the question.

4: The candidate had a strong answer to the question.  

5: The candidate offered an ideal answer to this question. 

Use your scoring sheet for every interview

Make it a point to use your score sheet as your interview every candidate. You can tailor the questions based on the open role, but maintaining consistency will help you make smarter decisions and get the best results during your hiring process. 


Need more help? Homebase hiring has your back. We’ll post your job description on the leading sites and help you find the perfect candidate by using our applicant tracking system to manage respondents from all the job boards in one place. 

Related posts

10 easy employee recognition ideas for when “thank you” just isn’t enough

Keeping your team happy and motivated should be high on your priority list — especially if you want them to…

Read article

Competing for new hires?
You may have one surprising advantage.

Ever wonder how your small business stacks up against the competition? Or how you could ever compete with the big…

Read article

You asked, they answered: Antique Taco on hard work, team culture, and more

Meet the owners:   Ashley & Rick Ortiz, Antique Taco With Antique Taco, Ashley and Rick are bringing together their…

Read article

You asked, they answered: Cadence Kidwell on starting and running a retail shop 

Meet the owner:   Cadence Kidwell, Fuzzy Goat Fuzzy Goat is a knitting boutique in Thomasville, Georgia, that sells artisan…

Read article

You asked, they answered: Christine Ha on opening and operating a restaurant

Who better to answer your questions about starting and running a small business than successful business owners who’ve done it…

Read article

Hiring students for the summer? Make a splash with these hot tips.

With summer just weeks away, you may be hatching a plan to build up your team for the busy season….

Read article