Setting Up Payroll for Small Business: A Complete Setup Guide

Remember your first hire? That mix of excitement and mild panic when you realized you're now responsible for someone else's paycheck. Setting up payroll for a small business suddenly becomes very real when you're staring at tax forms and wondering if you're doing it right.

We get it. You built something successful enough to need help, but between handling suppliers, managing customers, and maybe covering a shift yourself, the last thing you need is a payroll headache that keeps you up Sunday nights.

The good news: we've walked thousands of small business owners through their first payroll setup. We know exactly where the speed bumps are in the small business payroll process, and how to avoid them.

This guide breaks down the entire process into seven manageable steps that'll get your payroll running smoothly in 2-3 weeks. No scary legal jargon, no overwhelming complexity—just the straight path from "how do I even start?" to confident payday.

TL;DR What you need to know about setting up payroll for small business

Setting up payroll for small business requires seven essential steps: obtain an EIN, classify workers, collect tax forms, choose a pay schedule, select a payroll system, set up tax withholdings, and establish record-keeping. 

Most small businesses complete the entire setup process in 2-3 weeks with proper preparation. Following a structured payroll implementation timeline helps you stay organized and avoid last-minute scrambles that lead to mistakes.

Here's what you'll accomplish:

• Get legally compliant with federal, state, and local requirements
• Set up accurate tax calculations that prevent costly penalties
• Create reliable pay schedules your team can count on
• Build systems that save you 10+ hours every pay period

Essential requirements to gather for setting up payroll:

• Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the IRS
• Employee W-4 and I-9 forms for tax withholdings
• State tax ID numbers (varies by location)
• Business bank account for direct deposits and tax payments
• Workers' compensation insurance (required in most states)

Time investment: Expect 10-15 hours for initial setup, then 2-3 hours per payroll run. Using payroll software reduces ongoing time to under 30 minutes per pay period.

Bottom line: Proper setup now means smooth, stress-free paydays forever. Let's make your team unstoppable.

{{banner-cta}}

What you need to set up payroll: Essential requirements

You need an EIN, employee tax forms, business bank account, and payroll system to set up payroll. Essential documents include W-4 forms for tax withholdings, I-9 forms for work eligibility, state tax registration, and direct deposit authorizations.

Here's your complete payroll setup requirements checklist:

Business documents you'll need:

• Employer Identification Number (EIN) from IRS
• State and local tax ID numbers
• Business bank account and routing numbers
• Workers' compensation insurance policy
• Professional liability insurance (if required)

Employee information to collect:

• W-4 Employee's Withholding Certificate
• Form I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification
• Direct deposit authorization and banking details
• Emergency contact information
• Benefits enrollment selections

Before your first payroll run:

• Payroll schedule decision (bi-weekly is most common)
• Pay rate documentation for each employee
• Time tracking system for hourly workers

Don't let missing paperwork delay your first payday. With Homebase's digital onboarding, new hires complete all required forms before day one—no more chasing signatures or scrambling for missing W-4s.

Step 1: Get your EIN and required tax IDs

Your EIN application is the foundation of everything else—you can't hire employees, open business bank accounts, or file taxes without it. 

Think of your Employer Identification Number as your business's social security number. The good news? Getting one is free and takes about 10 minutes online.

Apply for your federal EIN

The IRS makes EIN application surprisingly simple:

• Apply directly on IRS.gov (never pay third-party services)
• Get your number immediately after completing the online form
• Have your business details ready: legal name, address, business structure
• Store your EIN confirmation letter safely—you'll need it constantly

Your EIN stays with your business forever, even if you change names or move locations.

State and local tax registration

Most states have specific new business payroll requirements beyond your federal EIN:

• Check your state's business registration website
• Register for state withholding tax accounts
• Apply for unemployment insurance accounts
• Get local business licenses if required

Timeline expectations: Federal EIN arrives instantly online. State registrations typically take 1-3 business days.

Step 2: Classify your workers correctly

Worker classification mistakes cost small businesses $50-$500 per misclassified worker in penalties—get this step right and save yourself major headaches down the road. 

The IRS scrutinizes these classifications closely, so let's make sure you nail it from day one.

Employee vs. independent contractor

The IRS uses three main factors for employee vs contractor decisions:

Behavioral control:

• Do you set their work schedule and methods?
• Do you provide training or specific instructions?
• Do you evaluate how they complete tasks?

Financial control:

• Do you provide tools, equipment, or workspace?
• Do you pay regular wages vs. project-based fees?
• Can they work for competitors simultaneously?

Relationship type:

• Is their work central to your business operations?
• Do you offer benefits or paid time off?
• Is this an ongoing relationship vs. specific project?

Example: Your barista who works set shifts using your equipment = employee. The web designer who builds your site on their timeline with their tools = contractor.

Exempt vs. non-exempt classifications

Non-exempt employees (get overtime pay):

• Paid hourly or earn less than $684/week salary
• Include servers, retail staff, most frontline workers

Exempt employees (no overtime):

• Earn $684+ weekly salary and perform executive/professional duties
• Think managers, accountants, specialized professionals

Bottom line: When in doubt, classify as a non-exempt employee—it's safer and protects your workers.

Step 3: Collect required employee documentation

When you’re setting up payroll, it’s good to get all employee tax forms completed before day one—nothing kills the excitement of your first payroll like scrambling for missing paperwork on Sunday night. 

Smart business owners make document collection part of their hiring process, not an afterthought.

H3: Essential tax and employment forms

Every new hire must complete these employee tax forms:

Federal requirements:

• W-4 form for federal income tax withholding (use the 2025 version)
• Form I-9 for employment eligibility verification with acceptable documents
• Direct deposit authorization with banking details and voided check

State-specific needs:

• State withholding certificates (varies by location)
• New hire reporting forms (due within 20 days in most states)
• Workers' compensation acknowledgments

Benefits and emergency information

Don't forget the supporting employee paperwork when you’re setting up payroll:

• Emergency contact details and medical information
• Health insurance enrollment forms (if offered)
• PTO policy acknowledgments and accrual agreements
• Employee handbook receipt confirmation

We recommend creating a new hire packet that includes everything. Hand it to them on interview day so they can complete forms at home without pressure.

Step 4: Choose your payroll schedule

Your payroll schedule affects everything from cash flow to employee satisfaction—pick one that works for your business and stick to it religiously. 

Most small businesses choose bi-weekly payroll because it balances manageable cash flow with happy employees who prefer frequent paychecks.

Pay frequency options:

• Weekly: 52 payrolls per year, steady cash flow needed
• Bi-weekly: 26 payrolls, most popular choice for small businesses
• Semi-monthly: 24 payrolls, good for salaried employees
• Monthly: 12 payrolls, challenging for hourly workers living paycheck to paycheck

Consider these factors:

• Your state's minimum pay frequency laws (some require weekly for certain workers)
• Cash flow patterns in your business (especially seasonal businesses)
• Employee preferences—hourly workers typically prefer weekly or bi-weekly
• Processing fees from your payroll provider

The golden rule: Whatever schedule you choose when setting up payroll, never miss a payday. Your team relies on consistent payment dates to pay rent and support their families.

Step 5: Set up tax withholdings and calculations

Payroll tax setup is where most DIY attempts fall apart—get the calculations wrong and you're looking at penalties that can cost more than hiring help in the first place. The math isn't impossible, but it's unforgiving when you mess it up.

Federal Tax Requirements

Here's what you're calculating for every paycheck:

Employee withholdings:

• Federal income tax (based on their W-4 selections)
• Social Security tax: 6.2% on wages up to $176,100 (2025 limit)
• Medicare tax: 1.45% on all wages
• Additional Medicare: 0.9% on wages over $200,000

Your employer responsibilities:

• Matching Social Security: 6.2%
• Matching Medicare: 1.45%
• Federal unemployment (FUTA): 6% on first $7,000 per employee

State and local tax setup

State variations to track:

• Income tax rates (nine states have none)
• State unemployment insurance (SUTA) rates vary widely
• Local taxes in cities like New York or Philadelphia
• Workers' compensation premiums by industry risk

Payroll tax calculations in practice

Real example: Your employee earns $600/week. You'll withhold roughly $100 in taxes from their check, plus pay another $50 in employer taxes—$150 total in tax obligations per week.

Payment schedule: Most small businesses pay payroll taxes monthly, but weekly if your quarterly liability exceeds $50,000.

Note: Tax rates and wage bases change annually. Verify current rates at IRS.gov and your state's tax agency before processing payroll.

{{banner-cta}}

Step 6: Select your payroll processing method

This is the big decision that determines whether you'll spend Sunday nights calculating overtime or watching Netflix instead. Your payroll system setup choice affects everything from your time investment to your risk of costly mistakes.

DIY payroll setup

Going the manual route means you handle everything yourself:

What's involved:

• Hand-calculating wages, taxes, and deductions every pay period
• Manually filing quarterly tax forms (941, 940, state returns)
• Tracking vacation time and overtime in spreadsheets
• Writing checks or processing direct deposits individually

Time reality: 3-5 hours per pay period initially, improving to 2-3 hours with experience

Best for: 1-3 employees with simple hourly pay and no benefits

Risk factor: High—payroll mistakes cost $50-$500 per error, and tax penalties can reach 25% of what you owe

Payroll software solutions

Automated calculations with varying levels of support:

Core features:

• Automatic tax calculations and direct deposits
• Basic payroll compliance reporting and tax form generation
• Employee self-service portals for pay stubs
• Integration with time tracking and accounting systems

Cost range: $20-80 per month plus $2-6 per employee

Best for: 5-50 employees, growing businesses with standard pay structures

Full-service payroll providers

Complete payroll management from start to finish (including setting up payroll):

What they handle:

• All calculations, tax filings, and compliance monitoring
• Expert support for complex situations
• Guaranteed accuracy with penalty protection
• HR support and employee benefits administration

Cost range: $50-150 per month plus per-employee fees

Best for: Any business that values time over money, complex pay structures, multiple locations

Bottom line: Your time is worth something. Calculate what 10+ hours per month of your time costs, then compare that to payroll service provider fees.

Step 7: Establish record-keeping and compliance systems

Solid payroll record keeping serves as both your audit lifeline and compliance foundation that keeps you compliant long-term. Skip this step and you're gambling with penalties that can shut down small businesses.

Required payroll records

The government wants detailed documentation, and they're specific about tax record retention:

Keep for 3 years:

• Employee timesheets and work schedules
• Payroll registers and individual pay records
• Wage rate changes and overtime calculations
• PTO accruals and usage tracking

Keep for 4 years:

• All tax returns and supporting documentation
• W-2s, 1099s, and quarterly tax filings
• Tax payment confirmations and deposit records

Keep for 3 years after termination:

• Employee personnel files and I-9 forms
• Benefits enrollment and change documentation

Digital vs. paper storage

Smart storage strategies:

• Cloud-based systems with automatic backups
• Organized file naming that makes sense six months later
• Regular system updates and security patches
• Easy access for you, your accountant, and auditors

Audit preparation: When the IRS calls, you want everything at your fingertips, not scattered across filing cabinets and old computers.

How to set up payroll for one employee

If you’re just starting out and just hired your first employee, congratulations! Setting up payroll for one employee follows the same seven steps, but everything gets simpler when you're only managing a single person. 

You still need all the legal pieces in place, but the complexity drops dramatically—no scheduling conflicts, no overtime calculations for multiple people, no complicated benefit distributions.

Simplified process for single employees

Your streamlined checklist:

• Get your EIN (still required even for one person)
• Classify your employee correctly (probably non-exempt)
• Collect their W-4, I-9, and direct deposit info
• Choose a simple pay schedule (bi-weekly works great)
• Set up basic tax withholdings
• Pick a payroll method that matches your comfort level

Special considerations when setting up payroll for one employee

Common first-hire scenarios:

• Owner-employee payroll: You must pay yourself through payroll if you're an S-Corp
• Part-time vs. full-time: Affects benefits obligations but not basic setup
• Family members: Same rules apply—no shortcuts for hiring your spouse or kids

Growth planning: Set up systems that can handle your second, third, and tenth employees without starting over. Choose payroll solutions that scale with your business rather than forcing you to switch later.

Reality check: Even with one employee, payroll mistakes carry the same penalties as larger businesses—plan accordingly.

Avoid these common mistakes when setting up payroll

These seven first-time payroll mistakes cost small businesses thousands in penalties every year—learn from other people's expensive lessons instead of making your own. The IRS doesn't care if you're new to payroll—they just want their money on time and calculated correctly.

The costly mistakes we see constantly:

• Misclassifying workers: Treating employees as contractors costs $1,000+ per violation plus back taxes
• Missing tax deadlines: Late payments trigger 25% penalties on what you owe
• Incorrect overtime calculations: Forgetting time-and-a-half for non-exempt workers brings Department of Labor investigations
• Skipping new hire reporting: States fine $25-$500 per unreported employee
• Wrong tax withholdings: Using outdated W-4 forms or incorrect calculations means angry employees and IRS notices
• Poor record keeping: Missing documentation during audits can double your penalties
• Ignoring state requirements: Each state has different rules—federal compliance isn't enough

Prevention strategies that actually work:

• Double-check worker classifications using IRS guidelines
• Set calendar reminders for all tax deadlines (quarterly, annual, deposits)
• Use current-year tax tables and forms only
• Keep digital backups of everything
• Review state labor laws annually for changes

Bottom line: These are business-threatening mistakes that proper payroll systems prevent entirely. Avoid payroll penalties by getting it right from day one.

Frequently asked questions about setting up payroll for small business

These are the real questions we get from small business owners every day about setting up payroll—the stuff that keeps you awake Sunday night before your first payroll run. No sugar-coating, just straight answers to help you move forward with setting up payroll confidently.

How do I set up payroll for the first time?

First time payroll setup follows seven core steps: Get your EIN, classify workers, collect employee forms, choose a pay schedule, set up tax withholdings, select a payroll method, and establish record-keeping systems. The entire process typically takes 2-3 weeks for new employers who stay organized and don't procrastinate on paperwork.

What happens if I make payroll setup mistakes?

Penalties hit fast and hard. Worker misclassification costs $1,000+ per violation. Late tax payments trigger 25% penalties. Incorrect overtime calculations bring Department of Labor investigations. Missing new hire reporting gets you $25-$500 state fines per employee. The good news? Most mistakes are preventable with proper systems and attention to detail.

How much does payroll setup cost?

DIY setup costs under $100 for basic software and forms, but requires 10-15 hours of your time initially. Payroll software runs $20-80 monthly plus per-employee fees, handling calculations automatically. Full-service providers cost $50-150 monthly but manage everything including tax filings and compliance monitoring.

Can I change my payroll setup later?

Yes, but some changes are easier than others. Switching pay schedules requires employee notification and cash flow adjustments. Changing from DIY to software is straightforward. Moving between payroll providers involves data transfer and setup time. Plan your initial choices carefully to minimize future disruptions.

Do I need special software for payroll?

Not legally required, but practically essential for most businesses. Manual calculations work for 1-2 employees with simple pay, but software prevents costly mistakes and saves hours every pay period.

Conclusion: Ready to set up your payroll system?

Setting up payroll for a small business can be a complex process, but it doesn't have to keep you up at night—you've got the roadmap, now it's time to make it happen. 

These seven steps will get you from "how do I even start?" to confident, compliant paydays that your team can count on.

Your next moves:

• Gather your business documents and apply for that EIN
• Collect employee paperwork before their first day
• Choose a payroll method that fits your time and budget
• Set up systems that'll scale as your team grows

Track your success: Accurate paychecks delivered on time, zero tax penalties, and a team that trusts you've got their backs. That's what unstoppable teams are built on.

Remember, every successful business owner has been exactly where you are right now—staring at payroll setup and wondering if they can pull it off. You absolutely can.

Ready to make your team unstoppable? Homebase takes the complexity out of payroll setup with guided onboarding, automatic calculations, and built-in compliance protection—so you can focus on growing your business instead of wrestling with tax forms.

{{banner-cta}}