Timesheet & Time Card Fraud: Tips to Protect Your Business

As a business owner, you need to be aware of the growing issue of timesheet fraud. When employees falsify their work hours, they're basically getting paid for time they didn't actually work. Over time, this can become a significant financial burden on your company. But it's not just about the money - timesheet fraud can also have a negative impact on your resource planning, project management, and employee morale. Inaccurate billing and payroll caused by timesheet fraud can make it tough to plan for the future. It can also lead to issues with employee discipline and trust. While it isn’t always easy to prevent timesheet fraud, there are some practical steps you can take to minimize the risk.

What is a Timesheet?

A timesheet is a tool that business owners use to keep track of how much time their employees spend on work-related tasks. Timesheets used to be just tables on paper, but these days, you're more likely to see online timesheets that offer real-time functionality. Timesheets are used to track your employees’ work hours and time entries. They’re also used to calculate payroll for employees paid for the number of hours they work. If you're tired of dealing with the hassle of paper timesheets, you might want to check out Homebase's free online timesheet app. Online timesheets allow you to automate calculations for things like billable time, which can be a huge time-saver when it comes to calculating payroll . Homebase’s timesheet tool can also help you manage your employee hours more efficiently. You won't have to worry about mistakes or discrepancies that can add up with manual record-keeping.

Homebase's online timesheet tool helps you keep accurate records

What is a Time Card?

A time card is a physical or electronic record used to track the hours worked by an employee. It is typically used to record when an employee starts and finishes their work each day, and it may also include the specific times when they begin and end various tasks throughout their shift. Time cards are essential for payroll purposes, as they help determine the total hours an employee has worked during a pay period and, consequently, their compensation. They can also be used for project costing, job estimation, tracking, management, client billing, and ensuring compliance with labor and government regulations. Time cards can be made of cardboard or other materials and are often inserted into a time clock that stamps the time in and out on the card. In modern applications, time cards can also refer to electronic timesheets or software applications (time card apps) that track work hours digitally, offering more accuracy and efficiency than manual methods. These electronic systems can reduce errors, are easier to read and process, and can be accessed remotely, which is beneficial for managing a mobile or remote workforce.

What is Timesheet Fraud?

In many workplaces, employees are responsible for filling out their timesheets, and it's up to managers to double-check that the information is correct. Unfortunately, some workers try to game the system by submitting false information in order to get paid for more hours than they actually worked. This is what timesheet fraud is. You'd be surprised how much time can add up even in small instances of timesheet fraud (also called buddy punching in certain instances). Let's say an employee adds just 10 minutes to their timesheet every day. It doesn't seem like a lot, but if everyone on your team did the same thing, those extra minutes could snowball into hours or even days of lost productivity. And guess who ends up paying for it? That's right, you do. That’s why it’s crucial to learn how to prevent timesheet fraud to avoid these kinds of losses and keep your business running smoothly.

How to Prevent Falsifying Timesheets

Timesheet fraud can result in lost productivity, incorrect payroll, and decreased profits at your business. It’s always best to be proactive and take actions to prevent timesheet fraud before it happens. These include implementing strict policies, monitoring employee work hours, and implementing digital timekeeping systems like Homebase to track your employees’ time and attendance.

Develop a Clear Time Theft Policy

It’s important to create a clear policy that outlines what behaviors are considered time theft and the consequences of breaking the rules. You'll want to communicate the policy to your employees in person and have it easily accessible at all times via an employee handbook. Make sure to explain why the policy was created and answer any questions they may have, so everyone is on the same page. To avoid any potential issues, it's important to make sure all employees understand the company's policies about clocking in for others and the consequences for not following them. By doing this, you'll help ensure that everyone understands the expectations and consequences of time theft in the workplace. This can help discourage timesheet fraud before it happens.

Use Time Tracking Software

Digital time tracking systems are more accurate than manual timesheets and can save you time from manual data entry. With time tracking software like Homebase, employees can use their phones to clock in and out automatically at their workstations, which helps prevent fraud. Additionally, mobile clock-in apps are a great option, as they allow employees to clock in using their phones, while following location restrictions. By using a digital time clock system like Homebase, you can keep more accurate records and prevent any potential time theft. With Homebase time tracking and timesheets, you and your managers can cut the amount of time you spend on payroll by 75% — so you could save almost four hours each pay period.

Conduct Regular Timesheet Audits

Regular timesheet audits can help you catch time clock fraud before it becomes a bigger problem. It’s important to review employee timesheets regularly and cross-reference them with other data points like pay data or your payroll budget. By doing this, you can identify discrepancies and inconsistencies in your timesheets and take corrective action quickly. Regular audits also send a message to employees that your business takes time theft seriously and actively monitors for it.

Instill Strict Timesheet Submission Policies

Establish some strict policies that dictate the exact time by which employees need to submit their timesheets. This will motivate them to record their work hours accurately and submit their timesheets promptly, without any room for guessing their work hours after working for several days. If employees often forget to submit their timesheets, no problem. Not only does Homebase offer a timesheet app free of charge, but it won’t let employees forget to submit their timesheets in time for payroll.

The Homebase app makes submitting timesheets simple and easy for your team

To tackle fraudulent practices like buddy punching, it's important to review the schedule and workloads in addition to the timesheets. This means taking a closer look at when employees are scheduled to work and how much work they're expected to do. Sometimes employees may ask their colleagues to clock in on their behalf if they're not available at work during the required time. By conducting regular reviews, every employee can be held accountable for sticking to the prescribed work schedule.

‍Foster a Culture of Transparency and Open Communication

‍Preventing timesheet fraud isn't just about implementing policies and procedures - it's also about creating a culture of honesty and transparency in your workplace. Make it clear to your employees that you value their honesty and that you won't tolerate any form of fraud or dishonesty. Encourage open communication, and create a safe environment where employees feel comfortable reporting any suspicious behavior they observe. Recognize and reward employees who are honest and follow company policies, and make it clear that there will be consequences for those who engage in time clock fraud.

Train Managers on How to Spot Timesheet Fraud

Managers and supervisors play a critical role in preventing timesheet fraud. They need to understand the importance of accurate timekeeping and be able to recognize the signs of time clock fraud. Consider providing training and education to your managers and supervisors on how to spot time clock fraud and what steps to take if they suspect it's happening. It's also important to make sure your managers and supervisors are modeling the behavior you want to see in your employees. They should always follow time and attendance policies and procedures themselves and lead by example.

Different Types of Time Card Fraud

Clocking In/Out Too Early or Late

This is common in businesses that still use physical timesheets. Manual timesheets can make it easy for employees to write down incorrect clock in and clock out times. Sometimes the error is intentional and sometimes it’s an honest mistake. This type of time clock fraud can lead to overpayment and decreased productivity since it can distort the actual working hours of employees. Homebase’s digital timesheets make the errors very easy to correct, so if the fraud is in fact an accident, it can be easily fixed.

Taking Longer or Extra Breaks

Employees taking longer-than-normal breaks can have a big impact on your team’s productivity, while also being unfair to other employees who follow the schedule. It's also important to remember that even taking unauthorized breaks during work hours can be considered time theft. Some employees tend to use their lunch or coffee breaks to run personal errands or simply take longer than necessary. To tackle this issue, consider implementing an employee break time policy in your employee handbook to ensure breaks are reasonable and consistent for everyone.

Buddy Punching

Buddy punching is one of the most common types of timesheet fraud. In this scenario, one employee inputs incorrect arrival and leaving times for their coworker. This type of fraud can lead to distorted records of employee work hours, resulting in inaccurate payroll and lost productivity. When it comes to time theft in the form of buddy punching, the Homebase time clock prevents this practice easily. With the Homebase free time clock app, you won't just be able to catch employees who forget to clock out after a shift. It also snaps a photo of the person clocking in or out, which means you can easily spot if someone is clocking in for another employee who hasn't started their shift yet or who isn't even supposed to be working that day. Falsifying Timesheets Falsifying timesheets is a serious offense that can lead to legal consequences and reputation damage for your business. It can also create an unfair advantage for the employee who commits the fraud, leading to decreased morale among other employees.

‍Favoritism

Unlike other forms of time fraud, favoritism happens when you or your managers show preferential treatment to certain employees. This type of time fraud often involves management overlooking absenteeism, lateness, or extended breaks for an employee they have a personal connection with or like more than other employees.

‍The Impact of Time Clock Fraud

‍The negative consequences of time clock fraud aren’t just about your business losing money. Timesheet fraud can impact your resource planning, project management, and even employee morale. When workers falsify their hours, it can make it hard for you to figure out how long projects will take and how much they'll cost. This can lead to mistakes in billing and payroll, which can be a big headache for everyone involved. And that's not all. Timesheet fraud can also damage the relationship between you and your employees. If your employees feel like they can cheat the system, it can create a culture of dishonesty and mistrust. This can bring down employee morale and, in the long run, hurt your team’s productivity and your business’ profits.

Legal Implications of Time Card Fraud

Time card fraud, often referred to as timesheet fraud, isn't just a financial issue for businesses; it carries significant legal implications. Under federal statutes, such as 18 U.S.C. § 641 and 18 U.S.C. § 1343, time card fraud can be classified as embezzlement or fraud. These laws address the theft of public money and fraud via electronic means, respectively. The penalties for such offenses are severe, with potential fines and imprisonment depending on the gravity of the violation. For example, under 18 U.S.C. § 641, an employee found guilty of embezzlement could face up to ten years in prison, depending on the value involved. Similarly, 18 U.S.C. § 1343 includes penalties of fines or imprisonment for up to 20 years. These statutes underscore the seriousness with which the federal government views time card fraud. In the private sector, employers may respond to time card fraud with termination of employment due to misconduct. Additionally, they have the right to initiate civil lawsuits to recover lost wages caused by time theft.

State-Specific Regulations

Each state has its approach to handling time card fraud, with varying degrees of severity in penalties. For instance:

1. California: Recognizes time card fraud as a criminal offense with possible imprisonment of up to three years.
2. Michigan: Treats time card fraud under embezzlement and larceny laws, with penalties including fines and imprisonment.
3. New York: While not specifically mentioning time card fraud, has laws against theft of government time which could apply.
4. Texas: Has laws against workplace theft, potentially applicable to time card fraud cases.
5. Florida: Lacks specific information on time card fraud, but general theft or fraud laws are likely applicable.

Prevention and Policy Recommendations

Given the severe consequences of time card fraud, businesses must implement robust detection and prevention strategies. This involves creating clear policies communicated to all employees, outlining the consequences of engaging in time theft. Regular audits and the use of digital timekeeping systems, like Homebase, can be effective in deterring and identifying fraudulent activities. Training for managers on recognizing signs of time card fraud is also essential.

Time Sheet & Time Card Fraud FAQs

What Is Time Sheet Fraud?

Time sheet fraud happens when employees claim they have worked longer hours than they actually have. This dishonest practice leads to receiving payment for time not worked. Examples of this fraud include buddy punching, overstating work hours, or making false entries in time records.

What Are the Types of Time Card Fraud?

Time card fraud manifests in several forms. Buddy punching, where one employee clocks in for another, is common. Other types include overstating work hours, not clocking out for extended breaks, and ghost employee schemes where fictitious employees are created to receive payment.

How Does Time Card Fraud Affect a Business?

The consequences of time card fraud are multi-faceted. Financially, it can be a significant burden. It also undermines the organization's integrity, erodes trust among team members, disrupts resource allocation, and can have a detrimental effect on overall employee morale.

What Strategies Can Prevent Time Sheet Fraud?

To combat time sheet fraud, several strategies can be employed. Establishing and enforcing strict timekeeping policies, closely monitoring work hours, utilizing digital timekeeping technology, and educating staff on the importance of accurate time recording are effective approaches.

How to Handle Suspected Time Card Fraud?

If you suspect time card fraud, it's crucial to investigate thoroughly and discreetly. Maintain confidentiality and ensure any disciplinary measures align with your company's policies. The aim should be to uncover the truth while handling the situation delicately.

Is Withholding Pay for Late Timesheets Legal?

Withholding pay from salaried employees due to late timesheets can be legally complex. It's essential to consult your HR department and understand local labor laws before making such decisions to ensure legal compliance.

What Legal Penalties Can Arise from Time Card Fraud?

The legal repercussions of time card fraud vary. They can range from termination of employment to legal actions, including fines and potentially imprisonment, depending on the gravity of the offense and the laws of the jurisdiction.

Addressing Non-Fraudulent Timesheet Errors?

For timesheet inaccuracies that aren't fraudulent, it's important to have clear timekeeping policies. Educate employees on the significance of accurate time reporting and routinely check time records for correctness.

What Tools Help Reduce Timesheet Fraud?

Tools like automated time tracking systems equipped with facial recognition and geofencing can significantly diminish the likelihood of fraud. Additionally, conducting regular training sessions on ethical timekeeping practices can be beneficial.

Approaching an Employee About Time Card Falsification?

When confronting an employee over falsified time records, handle the situation with care. Start with general inquiries, making sure they understand company policies, then move to specific questions about the discrepancies. The response should be proportional to the severity of the fraud and consider if it’s a repeated offense.