Navigating Payroll Advances: A Small Business Owner's Guide

With inflation and economic uncertainty on the rise, your team is probably looking for a little more financial flexibility. Payroll advances are one way you can help your employees make rent on time without them turning to high-interest payday loans.

For small business owners, offering payroll advances isn't as easy as cutting an early check. This guide will break down the essentials: what they are, legal requirements, implementation steps, and the tools you’ll need to offer advances without worries.

{{banner-cta}}

What is a payroll advance?

A payroll advance is when an employer pays out a portion of an employee's wages before their scheduled payday. Unlike payday loans or personal loans, advances don't involve interest or fees and are repaid automatically through payroll deductions. 

It's a direct arrangement between you and your employee that only covers compensation for work already completed, not future earnings. This makes them a more secure option than employee loans, which are typically longer-term, involve larger sums, and may include interest with different repayment structures.

How does a payroll advance work?

Usually thepayroll advance process follows four steps: 

1. An employee submits a formal request for an advance on their earned wages. 

2. The employer reviews and approves the request based on their policy guidelines. 

3. The employer issues the funds to their bank account either through their regular payroll system or as a separate transaction. 

4. Finally, the advanced amount is deducted from the employee's next scheduled paycheck.

Most small businesses handle advances manually through payroll software. Repayment usually happens within one or two pay periods, depending on the company’s policy and state laws. 

Some employers charge administrative fees for payroll advances but many states restrict or forbid that in order to protect workers from additional costs.

Are payroll advances legal?

Yes, payroll advances are legal under federal law as long as they meet Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) requirements. The key rule is that any deductions to repay advances cannot reduce an employee's wages below minimum wage for the pay period. 

State laws vary, with some of them requiring written agreements or limiting how much can be advanced. For example, California requires all wage advances to be in writing and signed by both parties, while New York prohibits employers from charging any fees or interest on advances.

How to offer a payroll advance

Now that you understand the legal requirements and basic mechanics, let's roll up our sleeves and get practical. Setting up advances doesn't have to be complicated, but you'll want to get the details right from day one.

Here's how to build a system that protects both you and your employees. Start with a simple written policy that answers the basics:

• Who can request advances? Maybe employees who've been with you at least 90 days.
• How much can they get? Most of our customers cap it at 50% of earned wages.
• How often? Monthly limits help prevent dependency.
• How will they repay? Usually one paycheck, but sometimes two for larger amounts.

Keep your request process straightforward. Start with something as basic as a form where employees state the amount needed and when they'll pay it back. 

This isn't an employee loan application; you're just documenting the agreement. If you're using payroll software like Homebase, you can track these requests right alongside timesheets and scheduling.

The most important thing is to be consistent. Nothing creates more workplace drama than giving advances to some employees, but not others. Having clear rules that everyone understands keeps things fair and professional, even when you're trying to help your team through tough times.

Pros & cons of payroll advances

Before diving into the nitty-gritty of how to actually implement payroll advances at your small business, let's be honest about what you're getting into. Every small business owner who's tried payroll advances has experienced wins and headaches.

The pros of payroll advances

• You're helping your team avoid financial stress and those predatory payday loan shops that charge 400% interest.
• It builds serious loyalty because employees remember who had their back during tough times.
• It can give you an edge in hiring when bigger companies offer fancy benefits you can't match.
• The cost to you is minimal if you have the right systems in place.

The cons of payroll advances

• Without good tracking, advance requests can pile up and create cash flow headaches.
• Some employees might start relying too heavily on advances instead of budgeting.
• You'll need to handle requests consistently to avoid playing favorites.
• If an employee quits before repaying, collecting can get messy.

Most Homebase customers find that the benefits outweigh the downsides, especially when they have clear policies and the right tools to manage everything. The key is setting up guardrails from the start so you can help your team without putting your business at risk.

What are common payroll advance challenges & how to avoid them?

Even with the best intentions, offering advances isn't always smooth sailing. Small business owners often share similar headaches, but they've also figured out some smart solutions. Here's how to tackle the most common challenges:

Challenge #1: Too many requests coming in

The fix: Set clear monthly limits (like one advance per employee every 30 days) and stick to them. Use your payroll software to track requests so you don't lose count. Some of our savviest customers also offer financial wellness resources to help employees better manage their money.

Challenge #2: Cash flow getting tight

The fix: Cap advances at 50% of earned wages and limit the total amount of advances you'll give across your whole team in any pay period. If you're running a seasonal business, consider only offering advances during your busier months when cash flow is stronger.

Challenge #3: Employees leaving with unpaid advances

The fix: Always get advance agreements in writing and make sure your final paycheck policy covers advance repayment. Most states allow you to deduct unpaid advances from final paychecks as long as you've documented everything properly.

Challenge #4: Keeping track of everything

The fix: This is where good software becomes your best friend. Use a payroll system like Homebase that can track advance requests, approvals, and repayments alongside your regular payroll. It saves you from spreadsheet nightmares and helps prove compliance if you ever need it.

Best practices for offering payroll advances

So, you've decided to offer advances and want to avoid the common pitfalls. Smart move! While every business is different, there are some tried-and-true practices that keep both you and your employees protected. Here's what experienced owners swear by:

Keep your policy human but firm.

Don't get trapped in the "just this once" cycle. Every business owner knows that feeling. A reliable employee needs help, and you want to bend your own rules. But the minute you make one exception, your policy starts falling apart. Stick to your limits, but build in enough flexibility from the start (like allowing two-paycheck repayment plans when needed).

Get smart about timing.

Many businesses find that advance requests spike right before major holidays or at the start of school years. Plan your cash flow accordingly. Some owners even set aside a specific "advance fund" during peak seasons to avoid disrupting regular operations.

Watch for warning signs.

If you notice an employee requesting advances regularly, it might signal bigger problems. Consider having a private chat about connecting them with financial counseling or checking if they need more hours. Sometimes what looks like a cash flow problem is actually an income problem.

Protect yourself from turnover.

Always hold the last advance payment until after someone's given their two weeks' notice. Sounds harsh? Yes. But ask any business owner who's been burned by a walk-out with an outstanding advance. It's worth being careful.

Document everything (but keep it simple).

A basic form that covers the advance amount, repayment schedule, and both signatures is enough. Skip the fancy legal jargon. Just make sure you're both clear on the terms. Keep these records with your payroll files, not in employee personnel files.

Remember: If a teammate is faced with an emergency, like unexpected medical bills, it can be tempting to offer immediate financial relief without thinking about the consequences. But the goal isn't just to help your team through rough patches. It's to do it in a way that's sustainable and doesn't create headaches for your business down the road.

What are the best systems and services for payroll advances?

Let's talk tools. The right software can make the difference between smooth sailing and administrative headaches. Each platform handles advances differently, and what works for a restaurant might not work for a retail shop.

Here's a real look at your options:

Homebase

Built specifically for small businesses like restaurants, retail shops, and service companies, Homebase handles payroll advances as part of our all-in-one platform. 

• The system ties advance requests directly to worked hours from the time clock, so you can easily verify earned wages. 
• Employees can request advances through the same mobile app they use for schedules and time cards.
• Managers can approve or deny requests on the go. 
• The advance tracking automatically syncs with your next payroll run to handle deductions.

QuickBooks Payroll

QuickBooks Payroll focuses on keeping everything connected to your accounting system. While it wasn't built specifically for advances, you can set up custom payroll items to track them. The system works best if you're already using QuickBooks for your books since all wage advances and repayments automatically sync with your financial reports. 

The main drawback is that employees can't request advances through any self-service portal. You'll need to handle that manually.

ADP

ADP's payroll platform offers more advanced features as part of their broader HR suite. The system can handle complex advance policies, multiple repayment schedules, and detailed compliance tracking across state lines. It even includes automated wage verification and customizable approval workflows. 

However, all this power comes with a steeper price tag and complexity that's often unnecessary for smaller businesses.

Workday

Workday approaches payroll advances through a broader financial management lens. Their system can handle everything from simple advances to complex earned wage access programs. The platform includes strong compliance controls and can automatically adjust advance availability based on earned wages. 

But it's primarily designed for enterprises, and may not be a great fit for hourly teams.

Gusto

Gusto takes a modern approach to payroll advances through their Cashout feature, which lets employees access earned wages early. Instead of traditional advances, they offer instant access to earned wages for a small fee (paid by either employer or employee). The system automatically tracks available earned wages and handles repayment through regular payroll. 

While slick, this model works better for businesses comfortable with app-based banking and modern fintech tools.

Pro tip: When it comes down to it, most small businesses need something that just works without overcomplicating things. That's why we built Homebase to handle payroll advances right alongside your regular time tracking and payroll. Everything you need in one place, without the enterprise-level complexity or price tag.

What's the best alternative to paycheck advances?

Maybe you're thinking payroll advances might not be the fit for your business right now. That's a normal place to arrive at. Plenty of small business owners feel the same way. Fortunately, there are other ways to help your team avoid payday loans and manage their cash flow better:

Earned Wage Access (EWA) Apps

Modern solutions like DailyPay and Even let employees access their earned wages instantly through an app. They handle all the heavy lifting. You just need to integrate them with your payroll system. Your employees pay a small fee per withdrawal (usually $2-3), but it's way cheaper than payday loans.

Financial wellness programs

Partner with services that offer budgeting tools, emergency savings accounts, and financial education. Dave, Albert, and similar apps help employees build better money habits while providing small cash advances when needed. Some even include automated savings features.

Third-party emergency loan programs

Companies like TrueConnect partner with employers to offer small loans based on employment rather than credit scores. They handle all the paperwork and risk, while you just verify employment. Interest rates are regulated, and payments come straight from payroll.

The main advantage of these alternatives? They take the administrative burden and risk off your plate while still helping your team avoid predatory lenders. Just make sure to research the fees and terms carefully. Some services can get expensive for your employees.

The bottom line: Help your team while protecting your business.

Smart payroll advance policies help you retain good employees while keeping your business on track for growth. Whether you choose to handle advances in-house or opt for a third-party solution, the key is having clear policies and the right tools in place.

If you're not quite ready for advances, that's okay too. Consider starting with some of the alternative solutions we covered to help your team build financial stability.

But if you're ready to start offering advances, Homebase can help you set up a system that works. Our platform handles everything from tracking requests to managing repayments, all while keeping you compliant. 

{{banner-cta}}

FAQ

Can any employee request a payroll advance?

Most businesses limit advances to employees who've worked there at least 90 days and have good attendance records. You can set your own eligibility requirements, but they should be clear and apply equally to all employees in similar roles.

Do payroll advances require credit checks?

No, payroll advances do not require credit checks. This makes them accessible to employees without impacting their credit history.

Is a payroll advance considered taxable income?

No. Since you're advancing wages that will be earned in the current pay period, it's not additional income – just an early payment of regular wages. The income gets reported and taxed normally on their regular paycheck.

How often should employees be allowed to request advances?

Most small businesses limit advances to once per month or pay period to prevent dependency and maintain cash flow. Some also set annual limits, like no more than 6 advances per year.

What happens if an employee quits before repaying their advance?

You can typically deduct the remaining balance from their final paycheck, but you need to have this policy in writing and signed by the employee beforehand. Some states have specific rules about final paycheck deductions, so check your local laws.

Can you charge fees for payroll advances?

While you technically can in some states, most small businesses skip the fees to keep things simple and avoid potential legal issues. If you do charge fees, they must be reasonable and clearly disclosed upfront.